Critique Form

talk design
1

Hey everyone

I just read a post by EthanM, and it gave me a great idea! Why not have a form that you could fill out about a site while critiqueing (spelling?) it (i.e. first impressions, color schemes, ect.). I think that this would make the process of critiqueing a lot smoother and more helpful than the average 1 line post about how they should change somthing.

:slight_smile:

2

that is a good idea. It should have the standards…

Rate:
Load Time
Usability
Colors
Navigation
Content
Creativity
Layout
Font

…

3

I think it works great how it is; I would definitely not share my opinions if I had to fill out a lengthy form like that. The user giving their critique can just follow a personal guideline sort of like that if they want :slight_smile:

Cheers!
3dnirvana

4

I would definitely not share my opinions if I had to fill out a lengthy form like that

I never said that they would have to, i just meant that it would be much more helpful :slight_smile:

5

yeah, i agree, think that would be a lot more helpfull, i’m down with the form :thumb:

6

not mandatory tho…

7

not mandatory tho…

Agreed. :slight_smile: (you only use the form if you want too)

Now to lay out some basic questions.