Feedback please! Which Icons would you use?

Hi All,

Thanks for all of your help so far! My software application and web site are coming together and I hope to have them both launched soon. I am more of a coder than designer so I am taking the web site as far as I can and then turning it over to a designer to polish.

The first pic is of the app as it stands so far. But, I found another set of icons and I’m trying to decide if I should use them instead. The second pic shows both sets. Also, do you like the over-sized icons overlapping the menu bar? The icons also enlarge 10% when you roll over them.

Thanks in advance for any constructive criticism and advice!