how come it was only my footer that got ‘dissed’…grow up people! I was so exited to get on the list, then i get cut down…
mariofan!
(not really that bothered, got better things to do than stick up for my footer!)
well, I don’t think anybody else “dissed” your footer… And I wasn’t truly dissing it myself…
ya mario, thats why i voted for your footer in the first round. It is great, and original. Dont worry what they have to say. 
cheers alex! i wont worry! btw - GREAT AVATOR lolololol!!!
no has voted for me nor mdipi oh well, at least i made it this far. i voted for eisloe by the way, it’s uber cool
I don’t get yours zylum, they don’t seem to change anything for me?
- Soul :s:
I really like mdipi’s one… but I only get one vote 
brave to choose a static footer, I really like it though… :thumb:
*Originally posted by Supree *
**The lesson we learned here today is to let the people vote, instead of having mods choose. **
I didn’t include your footer, because it was simple, had no relevance to your username, or made any sense to me whatsoever. The design looked random, the colors looked random, and I had no idea what the robots were supposed to be doing. It looked like something my 14 yr old neighbor’s kid would have.
Now, do you really want to hear what I have to say after looking at over 50 footers? I’m sure it would not be as “nice.”
Rev
This is what i though of it.
Supree- the footer reminded me of the random circle FLA on kirupa labs home page. It didnt have a specific theme, and i did not get why there were robots in his footer.
:):player:
eilsoe: i voted for ya. I love the detail in yours.
zylum: how do u work yours. I couldt realy under stand it. it always looked the same no mater what settings did.
Mario Fan: I have lawyas loved your footer.
Oh boy. OK. I’ll admit that I did choose a theme that no one here is familiar with. :sigh: In my footer are Gundams. They are futuristic robots that fight in space. They are quite popular in japanese animation and plastic model kits. Well, I guess no one here knows about them.
But all also had this one:
[swf=“http://www.supree.com/footer.swf height=60 width=300”][/swf]
well, when you look at some peoples footer, they have a little description underneath… for some reason i didn’t get a description even tho i needs one. if you’re interested, then you could check my thread…
I knew what they were. Yah gundams are cool. And why does the footer have to do anything with your name reverendflasher??
Thanks Kit!
*Originally posted by Gecko *
**I knew what they were. Yah gundams are cool. And why does the footer have to do anything with your name reverendflasher?? **
Each judge has their own criteria to be met. If there was just a checklist there would be no reason for judges, just go down the checklist and check stuff off. But that was not the case here, a group of non-participants were selected to pick what they found to be the best, and they compared their results and took the top 15 from there.
Have you ever watched the show “American Idol”? Where at first there are millions of people trying out, but only 3 judges choose between the masses of people to see who moves on, then after that, all of America gets to vote.
That’s the situation here. All entries were judged by a panel of judges and widdled down to the top 15 according to votes from each judges selections, then those top 15 are put into this poll and voted on by the masses of kirupa forum.
I don’t really see anything unfair about that.
Whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa!!! I think you got me wrong there lost in beta… I wasn’t suggesting that it was unfair or anything. My post had two parts… first I was telling supree that I knew what gundams were. Secondly I was asking since when did the name have to do anything with it? I wasn’t complaining or anything sheesh… :sigh:
*Originally posted by Supree *
[QUOTE]*Originally posted by Jubba *
?
[/QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Gecko *
**Whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa!!! I think you got me wrong there lost in beta… I wasn’t suggesting that it was unfair or anything. My post had two parts… first I was telling supree that I knew what gundams were. Secondly I was asking since when did the name have to do anything with it? I wasn’t complaining or anything sheesh… :sigh: **
Um, ok then. In that case just the first paragaph of what I said is directed at your question.
i gotta say clownstaple had the craziest footer!!
i loved them all though…the one with the bouncy heads was a close second in my book!
Gecko:
I was meaning, that if your username was skywalker, and your footer was star wars based, then you got extra consideration (shows creativity and imagination if done right)…
Why do people have to whine after every competition?
Rev
