Getting a new g-ride!

So I was pre-approved for an auto loan from my credit union yesterday. I spent most of the day browsing used vehicles but I am so indecisive that I wanted your guys and gals opinion. I don’t want a used lamborgini or ferrari, just a economical, reliable, fuel efficient car that preferably is an SUV or Truck (6’5 230lbs) and 4WD would be nice! Any suggestions??