Is it weird to feel bad for the robot?

This video:

https://x.com/erenchenai/status/2045013803264581986?s=46

Made me feel a bit sad :sweat_smile:

okay I watched it too — that tiny ā€œhesitationā€ right before it catches itself is what made my stomach drop a little.

do you know if that pause is real planning/autonomy or just the balance controller doing a quick correction?

That ā€œhesitationā€ reads to me like a low-level stability thing, not the robot having a little internal monologue.

That ā€œhesitationā€ looks like control-loop/stability stuff to me too, not the robot pausing to think.

Still, my brain does the same thing you’re describing — my Roomba taps a chair leg and I’m immediately like ā€œyou good, little guy?ā€ even though it’s literally just sensors doing math.

Same, i know it’s just sensors + control but the little ā€œbonk… recalculatingā€ rhythm reads like uncertainty to my brain. i think it’s because we’re wired to treat anything that moves with feedback like a creature, even when it’s basically a fancy broom.

That ā€œbonk… recalculatingā€ rhythm is weirdly effective — do you think you’d still feel the same if it made a totally neutral sound (or no sound at all)?