Oh Gawd Help!

talk design
1

I am supposed to present a group project next week - I originally wanted to do the design. Another group member said she had a background in web design ( I don’t) and I said fine - Just yesterday she showed me her first page.

http://www.gelstoncafe.com/web/voice/Learning_splash.html

Am I over reacting or is this as horrible as I think it is?

I would like to do something more like

http://www.gelstoncafe.com/jhu/voice/newindex.htm

Anything constructive I can say?

Help!

Thanks,
Tobias

2

omg… the first one is pretty terrible :-
the second link is quite nice though :slight_smile:

3

OMG you are right. Boy that first one is TERRIBLE and I usually do not like to just come out and say something like that.
How you go about telling your co-worker is the hard part. I don’t know if you can not hurt feelings, whatever. Maybe you could just show your page to her and ask her what she thinks…
I would hope she would notice how much better yours is and realize that you need to go with that one.
Possibly ask her for some suggestions or some constructive criticism…say you were just playing around with some ideas, etc.
Good Luck!
:rambo:

4

Definetely second one is better :slight_smile:

5

Actually I really like the first one…???

6

AHHH!!! MY EYES WERE BLEEDING TO MUCH FROM THE FIRST ONE TO SEE THE SECOND ONE!

actualy, the first one… eh… no comment

I like the second one alot though, try to convice her to use that