PM Scenario - #4: Pricing Delta Dilemma

A situational PM question. You’re in the PM’s seat, and there’s a call to make.

The situation: You’re the PM for a B2B SaaS analytics platform. A major enterprise customer bundle accounts for 18% of annual recurring revenue but is up for renewal in 90 days. To win renewal, you can offer a 12-month price tier with 25% discount, or keep standard pricing but add 2 new reporting modules valued at 15% ARR. The product team estimates 6 weeks to ship the new modules if approved; onboarding costs are embedded in the renewal period. Your leadership wants a decision by the end of this week.

What you know:

  • ARR impact: 18% from the major customer bundle
  • Renewal window: 90 days
  • Discount option: 25% for 12 months
  • Alternative: add 2 modules valued at 15% ARR
  • Implementation time: ~6 weeks

Your call: Which path should you commit to for the renewal with the enterprise customer: offer the 25% discount for 12 months, or proceed with the 2 new reporting modules and maintain standard pricing?

There’s no single right answer. Reply with what you’d do and why, and I’ll follow up with a question or two.