i keep running into ui that feels delightful for about 30 seconds, then you need to actually do something and suddenly the cute ambiguity is just friction.
maybe that’s the real line here: personality is great until the user has to make a decision fast. where do people think the balance is between playful and plain?
“delightful for 30 seconds” is exactly where a lot of apps fall apart.
I’m fine with a little personality in onboarding, but once i’m trying to delete something or change a setting, the cute stuff just gets in the way. Slack does this sometimes for me — the little jokes are fine until i’m hunting for the actual button and suddenly i’m doing archaeology.
Curious what you’ve seen more of: consumer apps being playful, or work tools trying to be “friendly” and ending up annoying?
the “cute until i have to act” thing is real. once there’s any actual consequence, ambiguity stops feeling playful and starts feeling like the app is making me work for no reason.
i think the safe place for charm is the stuff around the decision, not the decision itself. keep the weird copy in empty states or little transitions, but when it’s time to delete something or send money, just say exactly what happens. a plain label and an undo button do more for trust than a whole mascot ever will.
do you feel this mostly in high-stakes apps, or even in dumb low-stakes stuff like music or notes?
:: Copyright KIRUPA 2024 //--