All good points. However, the site is kind of made for people who have been to the actual place… I know most sites are designed to get new customers, but this is actually more of a way for them to keep up with existing customers, and sell stuff and whatnot… Which is why our design goals are a little different, and why I think the craziness you see is sort of ok.
I know that makes it sort of impossible for you guys to really “get it”, but actually a lot of this craziness you speak of is exactly what this place is like, and exactly what we’re going for.
Theros, you’re right that it’s not that “beery”, but this place has a whole culture around it, which is more what the site is about, if that makes sense. Sorry, I know I’m being vague and difficult. And the sidebar is Flash because we want it to have some animation (it’ll have more later).
Nobody, that is something I was concerned about with the “collage” feel… I’ll try reducing the header a bit as dark suggested, and see if that helps the content stand out more. I’m finding it’s tough to keep a good visual hierarchy when the design direction is “make it wacky”. I know that’s no excuse though… I’ll see what I can do.
Dark, I think I do agree with you about the header being too large, and that’s something we’ve actually talked about quite a bit… We’ll have to see what client thinks. And thanks for the sprites link, I’ll definitely check that out 
skrolikowski, the pig and the bike are actually really important parts of this place’s culture, and definitely have to stay. That’s one of those things you can’t really get without having been there I think.
Ha I know I asked for opinions, and now I’m like “You guys don’t even know! You haven’t been there!” but really, you do have good points, and I’ll work on em.
Thanks 